Landmark Welcomes Incoming President & CEO

Posted: October 2, 2025

Updated: October 2, 2025

Timothy Mackay New Landmark Credit Union CEO & President

We’re excited to announce that after a nationwide search, our board of directors has appointed Timothy Mackay as president and chief executive officer of Landmark Credit Union, beginning October 13.

Tim brings three decades of financial industry experience and a track record of exceeding growth objectives, improving operational efficiencies, embracing emerging technologies and evolving products and services to stay at the forefront of the industry. His leadership style is rooted in collaboration with a clear vision for growth.

Tim joins Landmark from First Merchants Bank in Muncie, Indiana, where he served as president of mortgage banking and bank operations. Prior to that, he was president of Level One Bank and Level One Bancorp in Michigan. He also held previous senior leadership positions at Level One Bank and Fifth Third Bank.

Throughout his career, Tim has understood the importance of supporting the community personally and professionally. He’s been an active leader or board member for a total of nine organizations, dating back to 2002. His community-driven values are a perfect fit with Landmark’s mission and culture of building lasting relationships and strengthening community connections.

We also extend our deepest gratitude to Jay Magulski for his 12 years of dedicated leadership as president and CEO and 23 total years of service to Landmark Credit Union. Jay will stay on as a senior advisor until his retirement from Landmark on December 31.

“I am honored and excited to join the team and to build upon Landmark’s strong financial foundation and clear sense of purpose,” said Mackay. “My focus is on ensuring a smooth transition while continuing to empower dreams, strengthen relationships and embrace the credit union’s philosophy of people helping people.”

We invite you to join us in giving a warm welcome to Tim! He is looking forward to connecting with members and carrying forward our commitment to “Banking Made Easy” in everything we do.